Accused ‘Murder-For-Hire’ Plotter Lindsay Shiver Seeks Return To U.S.

The mother-of-three has been ordered to remain in the Bahamas on bail and must abide by a curfew and report to the police station three times a week. She has pleaded not guilty to the charges against her.

Shiver’s life took another turn of misfortune in October when her apartment was burglarized, and $20,000 worth of jewelry was stolen, including family heirlooms.

Details of the alleged murder-for-hire plot emerged when police began investigating a break-in at a popular waterfront drinking spot on Great Guana Cay, where Bethel worked as a bartender.

During the investigation, messages were discovered on Bethel’s phone that implicated Shiver and another man, Faron Newbold, in a discussion about killing Robert, who was visiting his family home nearby at the time.

The trio was arrested on July 21, and more incriminating messages were found on their devices.