BBC reporter Simon Jack was ‘hung out to dry’ by NatWest CEO say insiders with staff reeling from new row
BBC News staffers, still reeling from the Huw Edwards scandal, said the department had suffered a further blow after being forced to make an apology over its reporting to Nigel Farage.
Insiders expressed regret that BBC News has been dragged into another front-page controversy weeks after Mr Edwards was suspended following allegations that he paid a young person for explicit material.
âEveryone was hoping for a period of quiet after Edwards,â one news figure said. Staff have also been deeply affected by the death announced this week of newsreader George Alagiah.
There is sympathy within the BBC for Business Editor Simon Jack, amid claims that he was âhung out to dryâ by his high-level source withholding information over the Farage story.
Mr Jack is now on holiday after apologising to Mr Farage for the report on his bank accounts which âcame from a trusted and senior sourceâ who fed him information that âturned out to be incomplete and inaccurateâ.
Mr Jackâs apology came close to confirming that his source was Dame Alison Rose, who resigned as NatWest boss after admitting that she had indeed discussed personal details of Mr Farageâs Couttsâ account with the BBC journalist when they sat together at a charity dinner.
An internal investigation, prompted by Mr Farageâs call for an apology from the BBC, established that Mr Jack had gone back to his source to double-check they were happy for the information about the former Brexit party leader to be published and Dame Alison had confirmed that she was. He had also put the story, as he knew it, to Mr Farage for response.
Mr Jack, the BBCâs business editor since 2016 and who has worked for the BBC as a business journalist since 2003, has internal support.
âReporters have to be able to trust their sources. You should be able to trust the chief executive of a leading bank. He was told the decision to shut Farageâs account was in no way political. Simon was hung out to dry,â said a news staffer.
The BBCâs editorial guidelines on accuracy state: âWe should be reluctant to rely on a single source. If we do rely on a single source, it should be credible, and a named, on-the-record source is always preferable.â Dame Alison would ordinarily meet the criteria of a credible source.
There is relief at the BBC that Mr Farage, who established that the bank had political motives in closing his account through his own subject access request, has accepted an apology from Mr Jack and BBC News CEO Deborah Turness, and turned his fire instead on NatWest and the UK banking establishment.
âIf a very senior source gives you a good story, of course you run it. Thereâs no question about that. Some will say the BBC could have acted more quickly but thereâs no fault or blame,â Mr Farage told BBC Radio 4âs PM programme.
However, whenever the BBC is forced to issue an apology for errors in its journalism, it can undermine trust in the institution and give ammunition to its critics.
The Farage row exploded after Ms Turness launched BBC Verify, a new initiative designed to bring greater transparency to the broadcastersâ newsgathering and explain how stories are fact-checked before airing.
âWe at the BBC must urgently begin to show and share the work we do behind the scenes, to check and verify information and video content before it appears on our platforms,â Ms Turness said.
Ros Atkins, BBC Newsâs chief âexplainerâ, posted an analysis of the story, explaining why the BBCâs initial report was âinaccurateâ because Mr Jack was misled by his source.
Before joining the BBC, Mr Jack spent ten years in commercial and investment banking in London, New York and Bermuda. He has a degree in Politics Philosophy and Economics from Oxford University.
BBC news veterans say the broadcaster has been more cautious over its use of sources since the David Kelly affair, which resulted in the resignation of Director-General Greg Dyke and Chairman Gavyn Davies in 2004.
Mr Kelly, one of the worldâs top weapons inspectors, and a Ministry of Defence employee, had given a non-attributable background briefing about the missing weapons of mass destruction (WMD) after the 2003 Iraq invasion to Andrew Gilligan, a BBC defence reporter working for the Radio 4 Today programme.
The BBCâs claim that Downing Street had âsexed upâ the dossier detailing Iraqâs WMD threat to push the case for war enraged the Labour government. Mr Kellyâs body was discovered near his home shortly after he had been outed as Mr Gilliganâs source.
An inquiry led by Lord Hutton found that Mr Gilliganâs report that the government knew its â45-minuteâ claim over Saddam Husseinâs weapons capability was âunfoundedâ because intelligence chiefs believed their source was reliable.
Lord Hutton described Mr Gilliganâs report as a âgrave allegationâ and a slur on the governmentâs integrity although his verdict has been widely contested.
The BBC confirmed Jack is on holiday and declined to comment further.